Kevin Sparkman, indicating in a four star review by CCM Magazine, responds, "Don't worry, you won't feel dumb for picking up this release!"[2] Awarding the EP four stars at New Release Today, Phronsie Howell states, "Crowder assembles an outstanding live set, and Neon Porch Extravaganza lets those who may not have been able to see it be a part of the experience."[4] Mark D. Geil, giving the EP four stars from Jesus Freak Hideout, writes, "there's enough novelty to make the EP worthwhile, and the EP gives a good taste of just how much fun a Crowder show is."[3] Rating the EP four stars for 365 Days of Inspiring Media, Jonathan Andre describes, "Neon Porch Extravaganza, just like its predecessor Neon Steeple, is just one great worship song after the other."[1]
